
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA Case for Records Relating to Patriot Act Section 215
What's at Stake
In May 2011, the 糖心Vlogfiled a Freedom of Information Act request with the Justice Department seeking information about the government's use and interpretation of Patriot Act Section 215, which authorizes the government to obtain 鈥渁ny tangible thing鈥 that is 鈥渞elevant to鈥 a terrorism investigation. Our subsequent FOIA lawsuit to enforce the request compelled the government to release dozens of documents, although many others were withheld from the 糖心Vlogand the public. The 糖心Vlogcontinued to fight for additional disclosures concerning the government鈥檚 use of Section 215 to secretly collect Americans鈥 information in bulk, but the district court eventually granted the government鈥檚 motion for summary judgment in March 2015.
Summary
Section 215, perhaps the most controversial of the Patriot Act provisions that Congress reauthorized in 2011, is contrary to traditional notions of search and seizure, which require the government to show reasonable suspicion or probable cause before undertaking an investigation that infringes upon a person's privacy. Recent disclosures have shown that the government is using Section 215 to collect records of the calls made by every single American every single day, without any suspicion of wrongdoing.
In the days before Congress was to vote to reauthorize several expiring provisions of the Patriot Act in May 2011, members of the Senate Intelligence Committee raised concerns about the way that the Justice Department had interpreted and used Section 215. "When the American people find out how their government has secretly interpreted the Patriot Act," Colorado Senator Mark Udall said, "they will be stunned and they will be angry." Udall鈥檚 warning proved prescient when, in June 2013, it emerged from a series of disclosures that the National Security Agency collects from telephone companies, on an ongoing basis, the phone records of all Americans. Information collected includes on whom calls are placed to and from, when those calls are made, and how long they last. The 糖心Vloghas filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of this bulk collection under Section 215, and a motion with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) seeking the release of its secret opinions authorizing the dragnet surveillance of Americans鈥 phone calls under this provision.
This isn't the first time we've sought information about the government's use of this provision. Back in 2002, we filed litigation under the Freedom of Information Act that eventually resulted in the release of a few hundred documents. But it has become clear that the government is using Section 215 much more aggressively and broadly than it was back then.
The secrecy surrounding the government's use of new surveillance powers is unwarranted and fundamentally antidemocratic. The public should know, at least in general terms, how the government interprets its surveillance authority and how that authority is being used. It's shameful that Congress didn't insist that the Obama administration release this information before the reauthorization vote. We've asked the courts to do what Congress failed to.
You can read more about Section 215 here.
Click here to see the documents released from this FOIA lawsuit.
Legal Documents
-
03/31/2015
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - District Court Opinion Granting Government's Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 03/31/2015
-
03/31/2015
糖心Vlogv. FBI - Judgment Concluding Gov. May Withhold Documents
Date Filed: 03/31/2015
-
10/31/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Notice of Classified Filing
Date Filed: 10/31/2014
-
10/29/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogResponse to Government Supplemental Memorandum of Law
Date Filed: 10/29/2014
-
10/24/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Supplemental Memorandum of Law
Date Filed: 10/24/2014
-
10/06/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - District Court Opinion
Date Filed: 10/06/2014
-
10/06/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Memorandum and Order
Date Filed: 10/06/2014
-
08/19/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogLetter re: Supplemental Authority
Date Filed: 08/19/2014
-
08/15/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Letter re: Supplemental Authority
Date Filed: 08/15/2014
-
07/22/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogLetter re: June 2013 FISC Opinion
Date Filed: 07/22/2014
-
07/21/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Letter re: June 2013 FISC Opinion
Date Filed: 07/21/2014
-
06/13/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogReply Brief in Support of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 06/13/2014
-
05/30/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Reply and Opposition
Date Filed: 05/30/2014
-
05/30/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Supplemental Declaration of Jennifer Hudson, ODNI
Date Filed: 05/30/2014
-
05/02/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogOpposition and Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 05/02/2014
-
05/02/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Charles Sims
Date Filed: 05/02/2014
-
04/04/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Memo Supporting Government's Motion For Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 04/04/2014
-
04/04/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of John Clopper
Date Filed: 04/04/2014
-
04/04/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogUnclassified Vaughn Index
Date Filed: 04/04/2014
-
04/04/2014
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Jennifer Hudson, ODNI
Date Filed: 04/04/2014
-
07/29/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogLetter Opposing Extension of Time
Date Filed: 07/29/2013
-
07/26/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Letter re: Extension of Time (attached Clapper Declaration)
Date Filed: 07/26/2013
-
06/12/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - June 2013 FISC Opinion
Date Filed: 06/12/2013
-
06/07/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Letter Asking Court for Delay in Light of Disclosures by DNI
Date Filed: 06/07/2013
-
05/10/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogCross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 05/10/2013
-
04/26/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Supplemental Government Brief
Date Filed: 04/26/2013
-
04/26/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Supplemental Declaration of Mark Bradley
Date Filed: 04/26/2013
-
02/08/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Mark A. Bradley
Date Filed: 02/08/2013
-
02/08/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Vanessa Brinkmann
Date Filed: 02/08/2013
-
02/08/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Emily Daughtry
Date Filed: 02/08/2013
-
02/08/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Paul Colborn
Date Filed: 02/08/2013
-
02/08/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of David Hardy
Date Filed: 02/08/2013
-
02/06/2013
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Unsealed Declaration of Diane Janosek, NSA
Date Filed: 02/06/2013
-
05/17/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Order Granting Government Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 05/17/2012
-
04/23/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Supplemental Declaration of Mark A. Bradley
Date Filed: 04/23/2012
-
03/26/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - 糖心VlogOpposition and Cross-Motion
Date Filed: 03/26/2012
-
03/26/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - New York Times Cross-Motion
Date Filed: 03/26/2012
-
02/27/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Government Motion for Summary Judgment
Date Filed: 02/27/2012
-
02/27/2012
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Declaration of Mark A. Bradley (Feb. 27, 2012)
Date Filed: 02/27/2012
-
10/26/2011
糖心Vlogv. FBI - FOIA - Complaint
Date Filed: 10/26/2011
Press Releases
Secret NSA Documents Released in Response to 糖心VlogLawsuit